| 73Q Music Videos | Vote On Clips | Submit | Login   |

Help keep poeTV running

And please consider not blocking ads here. They help pay for the server. Pennies at a time. Literally.

Comment count is 15
SteamPoweredKleenex - 2013-07-31

When Jesus said "ask them," Jesus was, in essence, refusing to give first-hand testimony.

And listening to fucking Republicans rant about any kind of "age of reason" is like listening to homeopath be upset about the high costs of health care.

memedumpster - 2013-07-31

"And if you remember, Mister Speaker, the high priest said to Jesus..."

The lowest point in American government discourse has been attained.

SolRo - 2013-07-31

(Joke about how some of the senile fucks there are old enough to actually remember witnessing it)

(Depressed drinking)

Oscar Wildcat - 2013-07-31

Jesus also invented the electric lightbulb. It's true, ask the Jews.

Sanest Man Alive - 2013-07-31

Aw, I was hoping for Stephen King.

cognitivedissonance - 2013-07-31

Somebody doesn't know about the Inquisition.

Sivak - 2013-07-31


The Visigoths who sacked Rome were Christian. In fact, the leader, Alaric, was a Roman general. So the Roman Christians sacked the Christian Rome. Alaric himself brought the Visigoths there at the behest of the Bishop of Rome (later the Pope) and saw the sacking as his greatest failure.

Rome was an anti-intellectual society. They suppressed and killed innovative thinkers, for example Jesus and Archimedes. It's also worth remembering that, while the Greeks produced Socrates, they also killed him.

The Christians in Rome in fact damaged and destroyed a lot of knowledge, since it was associated with the former pagan order. Most of this damage was due to the collapse of central authority in the West, Christians in the East weren't so hung up about it since things weren't so bad where they were and therefore didn't think God was angry at them for some reason.

The monasteries in northern Europe and Ireland which did preserve leaning were outside the old border of the Roman empire and therefore were not Catholic, but rather 'Celtic Christian', centered in Ireland. This is a bit of a nebulous term, but it remains true that St. Patrick didn't convert pagans, he converted Irish Celtic Christians to Roman Catholic Christianity.

Martin Luther didn't think there was more than one way to be a Christian. He was convinced that anyone who read the Bible in their own language would come to the same conclusions that he did. He in fact had a terrible argument with the Swiss Reformation leader Ulrich Zwingli because of this.

Monasteries were centers of learning, but great advances in literacy and learning were more often pushed by kings and emperors like Charlemagne, who often butted heads with the Church. Historical works like the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, for example, were written without any input from the Latin Church and in the native language. These same monasteries were brought in-line with Rome following Norman Conquest and the appointment of Norman abbots.

And I don't need to mention the knowledge preserved by the Islamic world. Well, until Al-Ghazali fucked it up...

Rome is a terrible blight on Western history. It was an empire of staggering inequality, intellectual poverty, an innumerable slave population, and it celebrated this. The best thing it ever did was die, and the worst thing it ever did was create the office of the Papacy. And we're still sucking the Roman Cultural Cock more than a thousand years later.

SteamPoweredKleenex - 2013-08-01

What do you think of Terry Jones' BBC series, "The Barbarians?" It covers the tribes/nations that Rome destroyed and makes the case that the reason we see them as barbaric is that we had largely only Roman history to go by.

Sivak - 2013-08-01

I'm actually unfamiliar with it. I suppose I must watch it.

baleen - 2013-08-01

Yes, Rome revisionism is totally hot now. Fuck Rome. It did nothing right, and created few interesting thinkers. We also have to thank for it a completely fucked up concept of property rights and a ridiculous legal system. The concepts are so ingrained in our ideas of justice that it's impossible to think any other way.

Terry Jones' doc is great. He goes into the Vandals\Visigoths and the extermination of the Celts and so on.

The Mothership - 2013-08-01

Historian rant:

While much of your post is agreeable, several things are to be rejected. First, the whole 'Ireland preserved ancient learning' argument has been thoroughly discounted; far more texts containing ancient material survive from Italy and Gaul, in areas formerly administered by Rome. Secondly, the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle was composed in the vernacular, but it was maintained in monastic centers from at least the 10th century onwards, and by the 11th is is very clear that they were being updated by churchmen in Peterborough and Canterbury. Sorry to be pedantic, but that's what historians do, as you know.

Sivak - 2013-08-01

Hey, if I'm wrong I'm wrong. I probably shouldn't have become emotionally involved, but dammit he made me angry.

memedumpster - 2013-08-01

Every ancient government sucked, there wasn't a good one. No ancient empire did good things, that's not what they were for. The modern world is no different.

Bam, history!


Mister Yuck - 2013-08-01

It's kind of cool to watch someone make a totally fantasy out of bits of real history. A lot of creativity went into totally miss-educating this poor guy.

Jet Bin Fever - 2013-08-01

The description is spot on. I bet Jesus would love all these fabulous invocations of his teachings in completely inappropriate and incorrect ways.

Register or login To Post a Comment

Video content copyright the respective clip/station owners please see hosting site for more information.
Privacy Statement