I haven't developed an opinion on this video in particular (unless vague enjoyment counts) but it did suggest to me that P.C. could also have played Tony Iommi, who must hold the record for drummer-ignitions in the world (especially if restricted to drummers in one's own band).
How you feel about this comment is how I feel about the video. 5 for the experience as a whole
Even when this came out, I thought they did a terrible job of casting Paul -- doesn't look a thing like him. The eyes are all wrong.
I want to say that George's look is wrong too, except that would be akin to saying this movie would be better without Peter Capaldi, and that's like dividing by zero: a sin so grievous even computers are driven mad by it. No, I find myself wishing they went for a version of George who cusses like Malcolm Tucker.