HURF BLURF DUH
I daresay I'd rather have him back than Andy Kaufman. Andy would have gotten diluted and irrelevant, but Phil would have gone on being just as great.

Goofy Gorilla
Phil Hartman or Andy Kaufman? Has anyone ever had to think about this for more than one half of one second?

wtf japan
Nope. Sorry, Phil.

Rodents of Unusual Size
Phil was always funny, Andy Kaufman was hit or miss.

citrusmirakel
I'm still bothered by it too. I shouldn't care, I know this, but I do.

Innocent Bystander
You know an Andy who should have died instead of Phil? Clue: he's in the clip.

zatojones
Phil Hartman never required you to have some sort of secret and complex inside information in order to get his jokes