I like Ben Fry, I like Seed, I even like most of what she was saying. But I can't shake the feeling that the work these people are doing is not half as important as they themselves think it is. And I do design work.
The ideas are the easy part, though. I guess after spending enough time in design circles you just get "concept jaded", because everyone has these great mockups of things that you know aren't ever going to function in that state.
On the other hand, there can be something refreshing about an idea that hasn't been "road tested". Something naive and pure that forces you to think, which is what I assume drew you to this.
There were definitely lots of moments where I found myself saying, "yeah I never thought of it that way", for instance, the juxtaposition of people being crammed closer together but then having headphones to create personal space. It's a cool idea, but then she talks about coining a word for it ("exixistenzmaximum"...sure, I'll start using it, you know, soon) which is one of the things that prompted my first comment. The complete lack of humility.
No doubt. Design people suffer from their own form of social retardation, just like scientists, they just happen to dress better.
Not my favorite TED, in fact, my boredom was only punctuated occasionally by stuff I wasn't aware of and that didn't seem banal. This would have been a three if it weren't for the talking of using dead people to power sex toys. There's just something Legend of the Overfiend-ish about that!
Alot of this stuff is definitely cool, but the impressive part is the science, not the design.
Accessories For Lonely Men = creepy and not at ALL what I expected
|Albuquerque Halsey |
| Register or login To Post a Comment|