ztc
That's because this is a brilliant film, despite anime as a genre constantly gargling big fruity dongs.

Aelric
caminante, do you live in a world of black and whites? why can't we simply dislike a genre save for a few exceptions. i also dislike cops and am automatically on edge around them, but have met a few who were likable. see what i'm saying? i've liked miyazaki in general, but i hate giant fighting robots, therefore, i praise miyazaki and mock giant fighting robots. simple to understand, if you bother to try.

now, lets open the flood gates and all act like fat little children and argue for three days and be unwilling to acknowledge that different people thinking different things is ok, just like we did at the angel egg video.

Aelric
oh, and rating

Caminante Nocturno
Don't use your ten-dollar words on me, college boy!

Aelric
heh, you're alright kid.

NoCode
I have to agree with ztc here. From what I've seen, the majority of anime gargles big fruity dongs while Miyazaki shines way above the genre's usual mediocrity. There are some other exceptions, but anime in general seems to be a load of gay-ass bullshit.

I used to think that I was an anime fan, back when I was a teen-ager, because I loved Miyazaki and one or two other really great anime films I'd seen. Then I started watching more of it and quickly realized how soul-crushingly stupid the huge majority of it is. Then I found the internet, and that snuffed out any desire I had to declare myself a "fan" of anime.

Sorry, Nocty. You know I love you, but goddamn, your hobby is fucking retarded. And this is somebody who collects model horses telling you this.

Adramelech
I think the issue is that anime is not a genre, it's a general term for a wide sweeping manner of art and animation, encompassing many styles. To compare a Ghibli film or a political drama to a children's fighting robot show just because they happen to be from the same country and are both animated is insanity, much like the AMPAS blanket "Best Animated Feature" award.

It's like making up a word to describe all Western style animation, then using that to compare Spongebob Squarepants with a Ralph Bakshi film.

ztc
But there is no one 'western-style animation' as such. 99% of anime looks like it was cut from a very limited set of design templates.

Caminante Nocturno
Actually, there were only two distinct styles of animation in the Western world, those being Disney style and Hannah-Barbera style. Just about everything that came out from 195-something to 198-something else fit into those two rut-grooves. That only changed after, surprise, anime started influencing american animation. By which I mean more American animation companies started hiring the same Koreans to draw their cells that Japanese animation companies did.

None of this really changes the fact that you're all a bunch of closet anime fans too afraid to tell everyone how much you love Nanoha and Ranma 1/2.

Harveyjames
You guys are normally on the money, but right now you are retarded. Anime isn't a genre, it's just the Japanese (and French) word for animation. It's also a lame-ass term westerners use to mean 'all animation from Japan'.

The bottom line is this: There is some good japanese animation, and there is some bad japanese animation. Glad to be of service!

Gojira1000
Yep, I think Chet is right and we need to nix anonymous ratings.