|chumbucket - 2013-06-04 |
Never watched this show, don't plan to, but this was worth watching. Over and over again.
|simon666 - 2013-06-04 |
New Yakety Sax?
|violenza - 2013-06-04 |
|takewithfood - 2013-06-04 |
Why is anyone shocked by anything that happens in this show? It's season 3 already. Figure it out.
|Jet Bin Fever - 2013-06-04 |
|Bort - 2013-06-04 |
Nearly a shot-for-shot remake of Sam Peckinpah's "Salad Days".
|William Topaz McGonagall - 2013-06-04 |
Whoever made this was waiting three years to do it, wasn't he?
|cognitivedissonance - 2013-06-04 |
Interestingly, as the characters on screen were being murdered at the Red Wedding, so was the cultural concept of the Middle Brow, in exactly the same way.
Good episode of a good show.
I know what I'd mean if I'd said what CD said first:
The show is absolutely a stupid, guilty pleasure that the confused among us believe has middle-brow intellectual content. It has no intellectual content at all. It's gory, vicious, plotboiling, dragon porno that likes to break hearts by murdering almost any redeeming character and has not one idea in it. Nothing especially wrong with that as pure good-times TV. But for some damn reason people think it's vast and deep and true to life. There is something especially wrong with that.
I think we're used to popcorn movies and tv being so bad and so dumb, that once one is well-made, we start thinking it has something to say.
It's got plenty of intellectual content, middle brow intellectual content. Not too deep, not too shallow, it's a cut above your average popcorn flick - with plenty of flawed, dynamic characters - while not "saying" anything particularly deep or profound (unless you consider "incest can be fun!" to be a profound statement). I'd say that fits middle brow quite well!
As for the gorno, Shakespeare, Homer, and Chrischan were all bloody, vicious, and gory, yet I don't think any of us would argue that the presence of these things in any way diminished their work's cultural credentials.
I'm not saying that violence, sex, surprise or intrigue rule out or lessen any intellectual content. But in the case of GoT there's so much pulpy, good fun [and British accents] that it's making people confuse "This is good as in enjoyable and well-made" with "This is good as in meritorious, as in smart". Regardless of whether one needs more than enjoyability out of tv, there's nothing that pushes the show past "well-made high-concept plot-boiler with titties and chopping".
The characters are flawed, but not dynamic that I can tell. Who goes through notable changes? Jon Snow, *maybe*, Danerys *maybe*.
|subduralhematoma - 2013-06-04 |
The Rains of Keyboard Catamere
|Old_Zircon - 2013-06-04 |
Keyboard Cat may be the first meme to age well.
|Spaceman Africa - 2013-06-06 |
That was dumb
A good dumb
| Register or login To Post a Comment|