|Caminante Nocturno - 2007-09-09 |
Sometimes I worry that I don't have what it takes to be a Citizen.
Rather take my chances with the bugs.
|vecctor - 2007-09-09 |
Throwing these advertisements/news/propaganda segments in his sci-fi movies was always Paul Verhoeven's signature move. Great!
Though I wouldn't mind an ACTUAL Starship Troopers adaptation someday.
|boba. - 2007-09-09 |
the cow joke at the end of this was one of the best fuck-with-the-audience parts of the movie. in the theater, everyone was laughing at the cow slaughter and then immediately shut up at the dead bodies. I was laughing at the dead bodies part.
|Princess v2.1 - 2007-09-09 |
This movie only gets better with time
|Aernaroth2 - 2007-09-09 |
Man, this future kicks ass.
|athodyd - 2007-09-09 |
Wow, satire is easy!
OH NO I'VE BEEN DEFEATED
This movie is extremely impressive to people who have a profoundly simplistic view of politics (e.g. SolRo) and/or people who have never seen a good war/action flick.
It's a satire of a 9/11 world that came out before 9/11. Think about that.
No, Princess. Just...no. NO.
|Mike Tyson?! - 2007-09-09 |
I would like to know more.
|zatojones - 2007-09-09 |
Profound was my disappointment in Verhoeven's version of the mobile infantry
|TimbolinoBilchard - 2007-09-09 |
I liked how Rico went from a Filipino to Casper Van Diem.
|Cap'n Profan!ty - 2007-09-09 |
BRING ON DOOGIE HIMMLER
HA HA! You get a gold star, Cap'n.
|mr666 - 2007-09-10 |
This movie was pretty bad. Sure it had high spots, like this clip, but otherwise it was just buried under bad acting and bad writing.
|Wonko the Sane - 2007-09-10 |
Why does an execution get broadcast on 'all channels' but a cows evisceration get censored?
That's kind of the point...
|oswaldtheluckyrabbit - 2007-09-10 |
Here's a review I stole from somewhere:
Stunning, inexplicably overlooked monster movie that also happens to be among the year's most fascinating and subversive satires. It's hard to think of another movie (Leni Riefenstahl excepted) that uses Fascist imagery so blatantly - Nazi-style greatcoats and uniforms, soldiers standing in serried ranks bellowing in unison, recruitment ads in the style of the Hitlerjunge - and it doesn't even bother to camouflage its bloodlust with the soft-hearted trappings (parental bonding, filial reconciliation) of THE LOST WORLD or INDEPENDENCE DAY : this is an unabashedly militaristic future, where only soldiers have the right to vote and the Army makes a man of our callow hero - it's a clarion-call for violence, and it doesn't have a sentimental bone in its body. Yet - unlike the Robert Heinlein book on which it's (loosely) based - it's not (only?) a celebration of Fascist values : our heroes look almost reprehensibly Aryan (airbrushed teens, all teeth and cheekbones), at least till you realise they also look like the clean-cut kids on glossy TV shows like "Beverly Hills 90210" - and until it clicks that perhaps the "master race" isn't all that different from our capitalist glorification of the rich, the smooth and the shiny (it sounds simple, but if Gregg Araki was doing it every hipster on the planet would be salivating). Similarly, though the film's worldview seems politically incorrect to the point of barbarity, it's in fact based on the most ubiquitous shibboleths of 90s public life : men and women are entirely equal, racism is unheard-of, nobody smokes or does drugs, and, above all, uniformity (both cultural and, implicitly, political) has been imposed throughout the globe - in the film's slyest gag, these archetypally Californian teens are supposedly from Buenos Aires! It's just exhilarating to think of arch-joker Verhoeven enjoying his rich, multivalenced (if nihilistic) joke : on the right-wing redneck crowd who take the gung-ho aggression at face value, not realizing the military discipline is played so straight it's a hair's-breadth away from hilarity ("You kill anything that has more than two legs! You get me?" barks the sergeant ; "We-get- you-sir!" yell the recruits) ; on the weedy liberal types who find the whole thing objectionable, not getting the true message - that all attempts to substitute homogeneity for individual freedom are equally despicable, however "good" the cause ; and perhaps on the hapless studio that bankrolled the whole thing to the tune of 0 million, never realizing what they were in for. And the ultimate joke? All the above is just subtext, mere icing on the cake : the film is primarily a monster movie, and an outrageously exciting one, full of mind-boggling visual trickery and kinetic battle scenes - it's everything THE LOST WORLD should've been and more, the adventure movie as irreverent, in-your-face comic-book. Terrific stuff.
Mine: This movie is fucking awesome. The fact that people don't like it kinda weirds me out.
I think the satire is pretty obvious if you know what to look for, but they didn't make it so obvious that any idiot would instantly see it.
The whole court thing is pretty damn obvious though...'murderer' caught in the morning, found guilty by the judge same day, and execution is publicly broadcast on ALL channels.
I've seen that reviewer's site. He gave Waiting for Guffman and Scary Movie 3 the same score, and one of the highest scores on his site is for Jerry McGuire. I am easily prepared to take his opinions on comedy seriously, especially when his writing looks like someone writing fanfiction about Variety magazine.
|petep - 2007-09-10 |
You're lying to yourself if you don't think this movie is Pretty Alright.
|Princess v2.1 - 2007-09-10 |
"The supposedly libertarian Heinlein practically enthroned military power in the original book, a paean to authoritarian politics managed by the rough wisdom of the soldier-citizen. But Verhoeven's (best) movie satirized it brilliantly and absurdly along with war propaganda. It's like a WWII propaganda flick of the future, complete with archetypical, eager, handsome young heroes straight off recruiting posters, and brazenly manipulative newsreels. What scared me was how few people picked up on this and instead took the film straight - distracted by the special effects and violence perhaps. How, when this movie presents the most over-the-top satire since Dr. Strangelove? Is that how far both dumb literalism and the rote acceptance of everything this film mocks have come?"
Okay, by mentioning this in the same breath as Dr. Strangelove you have officially begun to piss me off. A WWII propganda flick OF THE FUTURE you say?!?!?!?!? Man, I'm glad someone finally had the courage to stand up to film archetypes from sixty years ago. I hear fascism sucks!
The website you draw this from is pretty unintentionally interesting--either it's some sort of retardo objectivist moon cult or it's a very clumsy parody of the same. Either way, they are exactly the kind of pseudointellectual FUPA Chups that Starship Troopers is meant to appeal to.
I never thought I'd see Fupa Chups again. This video has brought some happiness into my life after all.
Also, that site is incredibly awesome. Look for it on PoE when it cycles through the backlog in 14 months. One of the most solidly entertaining transhumanist spaz attacks since the Millenium site got featured.
|Xenocide - 2007-09-10 |
Damn Mormons. They never listen.
|Xiphias - 2007-09-11 |
Man it sure is great that chet added support for super-long comments!!
|Honest Abe - 2007-09-11 |
you're all faggots
|Roachbud - 2007-09-11 |
While some of the action scenes to this flick are unitentionally hillarious, it adds weight to the case that science fiction is not art, but garbarge. If he were dead, Ray Bradbury would be rolling in his grave.
science fiction has inspired more technological advancement than all the coloring paper in history combined.
Now go stare at some soup cans or something, art boy.
Science fiction is awesome. Heinlein was pretty crazy though.
5 stars for the awesome satire of his work and the "philosophy" some people have picked up from this book, -2 for trying to cloak it.
|Hooper_X - 2007-09-11 |
hey guys this movie was pretty alright and that redheaded chick had some nice ta-tas so i'm giving this one four stars okay?
|Syd Midnight - 2007-09-14 |
Satire, subtext intentions... this just wasn't a good part of the movie.
|Pacobird - 2007-11-02 |
I want a fully automatic burrito.
|Riskbreaker - 2012-06-24 |
Takashi Miike said this is his favorite movie. That just makes me love him, and this movie, even more.
| Register or login To Post a Comment|