Camonk
It's pretty petty to complain about the writing in a film that claims to have no script. That's like saying the fistfights in My Dinner With Andre are awful.

LeChuck
So I can't criticize a builder for constructing a shitty house because he chose to forgo blueprints? With a little scripting and some better acting this project would've been big screen worthy. Four stars is fair.

Dib
Try to look at this in relative terms. This is PoE, how many fan creations do we regularly see here on Care Bears, Sonic, etc. that are truly horrible?

When I saw this in the hopper, I was expecting one of those. The fact that I ended up actually wanting to see more certainly warrants five stars. The fact that this is created by fans and isn't a broken english fanfic about John Freeman warrants five stars.

fatatty
Honestly you don't even need that much money to produce this these days. Lets see, $1,000 for a decent camera, $3,000 for 3dMax (though stolen easily enough), $1,000 for Adobe Premiere and After Effects (also easily stolen), and most likely pro bono actors. $1,000-$5,000 and you can do the same quality special effects as Hollywood with enough time and talent (and torrents).

5 stars for the little guy one upping the big guy.

fluffy
In retrospect I see many similarities between this and District 9.

Michael Houser
Then they stole the camera as well.

Aoi
The Resistance is full of idiots.

If he was with Gordon Freeman, he'd be telling him to reload every 5 seconds, instead.

MerryMisanthrope
Yeah, that was my only quibble, aside from the acting. Also the headcrabs are kind of goofy. But the rest of the awesomeness made up for it.