i've seen enough o'reilly to have seen him at both his most embarrassing and his most smug. what i've never seen is a self-inflicted ambush by putting not one but two intelligent folks on his show at once. the usual producer must have called in sick.

Every time Bill O'Reilly says "far left," an angel gets its wings.

Notice from 05:19 to 04:24 it says "Ellis Henican: Fox News Contributor" but then at 03:36 and on it says "Ellis Henican: Newsday Columnist".

Even Bill O'Reilly must cede arrogant, smug, and lunatic territory to the idiocy of Michael Savage.

So, how often does it dawn of Bill that he's going to die alone and unloved?

Gets several stars for O'Reilly admitting to being wrong. Falls short because he didn't learn a lesson from it.

Oh my God it almost became a real intelligent debate towards the end. Best thing I've ever seen on Fox News; Bill really is a pathetic pundit who's ideology's can be easily reduced to nothing in the face of intelligence. Score one for reason and critical thought.

Boring.

... that's Stormy Waters? Holy crap.

I hope someone was fired for this screwup. Bill isn't supposed to debate intelligent people who disagree. And why weren't their mikes cut?

Putting any intelligent democrat in the same room as Bill O' Reilly is a cheap shot!

Yawn.

sweet:)

oh well, even the best comedians bomb on stage once in a while.

They were on the cusp of something beautiful there but unsurprisingly O'Reilly turned it away. He knows where his bread's buttered.